Planned Parenthood Golden Gate’s IRS/state filings a mess; former employees squealing
I reported last week that Planned Parenthood Federation of America is cutting ties as of September 3 with Planned Parenthood Golden Gate, which operates 7 clinics in the San Francisco area.
Well, the backstory is getting juicier as reporters investigate federal and state documents (or lack thereof), and former employees begin to leak information and internal documents to the press. The latest Bay Citizen piece provides the most details, while the San Francisco Examiner puts it all in a nutshell:
PPGG has been thrown under the bridge. Past donors included celebrities like feminist Gloria Steinem (pictured right with former PPGG president and CEO Dian Harrison) and Democratic strategist Donna Brazile (pictured on page 2, left with Harrison). But tax documents reveal that for the year ending June 30, 2009 PPGG lost as much as $2.8 million. Interim CEO Therese Wilson admits her group is in a “desperate financial circumstance.”…
The charitable trusts division of CA’s attorney general’s office said it had not received reports from the PPGG Action Fund for at least 10 years, warning that if the organization failed to file the required forms within 30 days, its registration would be suspended and its officers would be held personally liable for all late fees.
More dirt from San Francisco Bay Guardian:
A former PPGG employee with knowledge of the organization’s internal affairs described a longstanding pattern of financial mismanagement when… Harrison was at the helm. There was widespread concern about spending on expensive marketing campaigns and lavish functions, the person said, and a high level of employee turnover and discontent.
An internal PPGG document provided to the Guardian displays the agency’s on-hand cash reserves as compared with other affiliates, suggesting that the reserve ratios were at or below the minimum required by the national PP Federation for all but one year from 1998 to 2007 – and well below that of other affiliates of similar size. That is a key requirement for meeting accreditation standards.
If Harrison looks familiar, it’s because she was the inspiration for the heroine Dioanysus in PPGG’s ill-conceived 2005 viral cartoon, “A superhero for choice.”
Back to more dirt via Bay Citizen:
On October 21, 2008, 30 clinicians and doctors who work for PPGG sent a “letter of concern” to Harrison. The letter was also copied to Cecile Richards, the president of PPFA, and other executives at the national organization.
In the letter, the clinicians detail a myriad of problems in the organization, including their concerns about “the misappropriation and mismanagement of PPGG’s funds.” The letter accuses the executive staff of profligate spending during lean times:
… Executive staff’s personal expenditures are excessive and are not aligned with the mandatory fiscal restrictions. Flagrant use of PPGG funds to pay for personal belongings, personal services and exorbitant technology products is seemingly unchallenged and not subject to the same financial scrutiny that clinic supplies and staff salaries are, for example.
If PPGG’s finances were crumbling from 1998 onward, Harrison’s decision to remodel the Oakland mill, which I reported last year, becomes inexplicable. Here’s video from the architect.
Actually, PPGG went on a remodeling spree during the early 2000s, as evidenced by the numerous awards its obviously pricey architect Fougeron received during that time…
One last item to watch. PPGG was one of the CA PP affiliates named in the massive fraud lawsuit filed by former employee P. Victor Gonzalez. In July the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated that case, so it is still live. Who knows if PPFA has further knowledge of that case and thought this another reason why to cut PPGG lose.
[Photos via PPGG]
Wow. As soon as I heard her name (“Dian” which is a deriviative of “Dionysus”), I started suspecting.
I should run that character through the Mary Sue Litmus test, just to see… I bet we’d get one of the Sueist Sues ever to Sue. :P
The cartoon character’s name is even spelled “Dianysus”. Lolz, Mary Sues! :D
I wonder what “personal belongings” and “personal services” means in this case. They used abortion payments to finance their new cell phones and weekly pedicures?
Oh my this is indeed tragic. Let’s enumerate 1. not good to plan the death of preborn babies 2. not good to plan the death of preborn babies. 3. not good to pretend your helping economically disadvantaged moms by killing their unborn 4. perhaps when redecorating at the expense of economically disadvantaged moms or any mom for that matter one should get a real job!
Jill
When I come to your site and read all these good reports it brings healing to my soul. Appreciated your site before I got on facebook. Aprreciate it even more now.
Jill,
This is the beginning, and a great angle too. Get them on financial impropriety. It’s sad to say, but while the public will tolerate abortion, many of those supporters will not stand for their money being misappropriated and misspent.
Oh yea good thing they didn’t use tax payer money to go out to Asian bondage strip clubs or donor money to hire a male prostitute to “carry his luggage”….
The truth is that a bunch of San Fran liberals spent too much money on self promotion and being part of the San Fran elite to fiscally stop themselves from running into the ground. When PPFA found out they were told to fix it. They didn’t fix it. PPFA cut them loose. Give them about a year and they will restructure and bring in new personal and then reapply for accreditation with PPFA. This same thing happened to a couple Group Health affiliates no to long ago.
PPFA requires affiliates to renew accreditation every 2 years. I can tell you that the accreditation process takes a week and they look into EVERYTHING! It takes a month to prepare and put together all the information they require for review. PPFA is very through which is why you don’t see the types of stories you all read about that abortion clinic in PA or that doctor in FL.
This story, in my opinion, is not really newsworthy, unless you start reading conspiracies into the very mundane facts of this story…
Thanks Jill for all your diligence!
And the new format is working great now.
Wow the very first comment of ninek’s that I actually agree with lol The new format is working very well =)
Little by little PP’s facade is crumbling.
Um, no…
One affiliate has money management issues, just like every other major industry leader will have a “problem child” affiliate.
However feel free to blow it up out of proportion to fit your own agenda…
Biggz
By faith I’m agreeing with your second to last statement. I’m thinking it’s prophetic before you edit it. And prayerfully before long Camille Richards life will shine with true light. That’s commenting on your 6:39 post on August the 16th. I’m sure you meant thorough but I like through better.
Biggz said: One affiliate has money management issues, just like every other major industry leader will have a “problem child” affiliate.
That may be true – but every single one of us knows what Planned Parenthood does with “problem” children, and it ain’t pretty.
That cartoon is viral alright, about as viral as an STD.
Biggz: your faith in PP is touching, but did you notice how many years the excess spending went unnoticed? Not exactly a ringing endorsement of PP management. It doesn’t surprise us that hardcore PP supporters waste money and ignore the needs of women. PP is not about helping women even when they spend on their mission statement. We’re just enjoying the opportunity to make it clear that PP should never be taxpayer-funded. Maybe PP should receive more oversight since they have non-profit status? Hmm…-D