An October 28 Christianity Today article entitled, “The death of pro-life Democrats,” included this sobering observation:

Thanks to pro-life groups and backlash over health care reform, the Democratic pro-life vote in the House of Representatives is likely to halve on November 2, making abortion even more of a partisan issue.

The actual decrease according to the article: From 40-60, depending on the issue, to 22-35. CT notes these will “likely be replaced with more conservative pro-life Republicans.”

What Kristen Day, executive director of Democrats for Life, think the shift will mean, from the article:

From a Republican perspective, this is a very good strategy because you don’t want a strong pro-life voice in the Democratic Party; it takes it away as a campaign issue. The pro-choice groups are the same way. I think the pro-choice groups and the pro-life Republicans are on the same page: “We don’t want these pro-life Democrats in the party.”

And Stephen Schneck, director of the Institute for Policy Research and Catholic Studies at Catholic University of America:

To the extent that the pro-life movement tries to restrict the definition of being pro-life to the Republican Party, unless the stars realign and the Republican Party becomes 2/3 of the electorate, they’re cutting themselves off from the possibility of building the kinds of alliances that might be able to advance the pro-life agenda. If you want to do something about stem-cell research, or make progress on the whole of the pro-life agenda, you’re going to need some Democrats to come along. Going after pro-life Democrats is not going to help the pro-life cause.

Speaking from the other side was Marjorie Dannenfelser, president of the Susan B. Anthony List:

Assuming that our plans work out well, we will have a very strong team to work with, and a team that understands the consequences of undermining the pro-life position. They’ll see people who lost because they said they were pro-life and then didn’t vote that way.… Real movements behave like that; they don’t just say “well, throw me a few crumbs and we’ll be just fine.” This Congress will be very strong and we’ll be able to build on that.

What do you think?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...