Ask an abortion doc
I’m not sure if this video will remain live, the first version having been added June 10 and immediately removed, and I’m not even sure it’s legit. The guy does not look or talk like the typical abortionist you see/read about in the news.
Video title: “Ask an Abortion Doctor”
However, he raises good fodder for conversation. What would you ask an abortion doctor if you could? Seriously.
[Hat tip: Andrew St. Hilaire of blog The Transient Hour]
Jun.12, 2007 8:27 am |
Industry watch |
Jill Stanek is a nurse turned speaker, columnist and blogger, a national figure in the effort to protect both preborn and postborn innocent human life.
First I’d ask him how he sleeps at night.
Then I’d ask him what his children think of what he does.
Then I’d tell him that Subway is hiring, and while it might mean taking a paycut, at least his best friends wouldn’t come from “down under”, and I don’t mean Australia!
Then I’d ask to see his hands. Ask if he’s ever seen MacBeth…Out Blood Stains. Out! I’d ask him what kind of soap he uses, and if it works under the fingernails as well as under the heart…
Then I’d have to find a toilet to throw up!
Jill,
It’s not good to stereotype a person based on their profession (just like it’s bad to do with their skin, gender or religion). All the news you hear about abortion doctors who have molested their patients, and you’re automatically going to imagine an ugly person. Just b/c he’s in a certain profession doesnt mean he is ugly on the outside..
Then I’d have to find a toilet to throw up!
(All the time hoping that I wouldn’t find a dead baby floating in it of course.
Midnite,
Ted Bundy was pretty good looking on the outside too. However, I’m much more interested in the “inside”…I imagine abortion “doctors” are pretty ugly…
MK,
Ted Bundy had a mental disorder; I am pretty sure abortion doctors do no.
NEW DISCUSSION:
(we got along so well last night, dont want to light a fire now)..
How’s the weather?
Hey “doc”,
why are there fangs poping out of your mouth when you smile..
I’d ask him why he decided to kill children for a living, and then I’d ask him how he REALLY feels about women who have abortions. Then I would ask him if if he molested his good looking patients like all other abortionists do.
Here’s one Jill,
Field-trip for middle school students to PP!
http://www.thebostonchannel.com/news/13472081/detail.html?rss=bos&psp=news
The YMCA said it was the first time they took the students to Planned Parenthood and that abortion was never discussed. The organization said it will not take students there anymore.
Something is fishy about this video. I don’t think he is a real abortion doctor. Why does he have 3-d videos of babies being born in his favorites?
Notice he doesnt mention abortion in the video, but in the description it says “ask an abortion doctor”. I’m wondering if the person in the video is a legitimate doctor who made this video for other types of questions, and someone else found the video and is using the video for fun, to see what kind of response it will get with this kind of context?
The man in the video seems way too happy to be an abortion doctor. I have watched videos with all kinds of abortion doctors and NONE of them had this type of demeanor.
Maybe he is a gynocologist (sp?) and not a perverted spawn of satan.
Maybe someone as a cruel joke on this guy, knowing that as a gynocologist (sp?) he has in the past performed an abortion, put this up to get people to email him with unfair questions like “do you rape all your patients?” or “do you drink the blood of all the children you have murdered?”
I don’t think it’s legit.
I think I’d ask him what he thinks of his patients. I’d ask him how he and his family deal with all the threats and hostility from the right-wing nut jobs, and if he feels that strongly that abortion is worthy cause justifying these stresses.
Abortion Doctor is an oxymoron.
Look at the Russian abortion video at the bottom right when this video finishes.
It’s heartbreaking to realize that abortions take place every second of the day around the world.
We truly live in a fallen world.
Per Midnite:
“It’s not good to stereotype a person based on their profession (just like it’s bad to do with their skin, gender or religion). All the news you hear about abortion doctors who have molested their patients, and you’re automatically going to imagine an ugly person. Just b/c he’s in a certain profession doesnt mean he is ugly on the outside.”
Midnite,
I think you have missed the point here. Any abortionist is an ugly person both on the inside and outside. I really don’t consider this a legitimate profession.
Setting aside any news of sexual crimes against aboriotion patients. I have a hard time not stereotyping murderers for what they are.
It makes it worse that they make money doing it.
I have always wondered many of the sames questions MK brought up.
A few more:
How can you know there is a precious innocent live baby nestled safely in it’s mother’s womb one minute and you then violently grab at a leg or an arm like you are fishing and then proceed to tear a baby apart with force limb from limb and then lay the pieces on a table to be accounted for?
Do these babies ever have their eyes open and look at you?
Do you feel any emotion or remorse for what you do?
Do you really feel like you make an honest living?
How do possibly live with yourself?
Do you ever have nightmares about your job?
Midnite, it’s all ugly. Anyone who would do this is ugly.
His Man, I watched that video. That was tragic!
I’d ask how many death threats has he had so far, and what he thought of his patients.
I’d also ask why he’d chose this profession, when it’s likely that he’d end up beaten or dead by some crazed pro-lifer.
Then I’d ask him how he deals with accusatory questions from random people asking him if he’s the spawn of the devil or if he enjoyed raping all his patients because that’s what abortionists do. *rolls eyes*
Let me specify that I know not all pro-lifers are crazed. One this site, you’ve really got to cover your ass or someone’ll bite it off.
look at the video 2nd from right…. at top
“Then I would ask him if if he molested his good looking patients like *all* other abortionists do.” That’s quite an accusation.
Maybe I’m missing something in the words, do you guys mean doctors who work at abortion clinics or doctors who perform abortions and also do other things, lilke deliver babies?
Midnite, 8:56a, said: “It’s not good to stereotype a person based on their profession…. Just b/c he’s in a certain profession doesnt mean he is ugly on the outside.”
Midnite, they’re called stereotypes for a reason. Based on this guy’s looks and demeanor, i.e., apparent bedside manner, he does not fit the profile of an abortionist. Sorry, not pc here. No cream of the crop doc aspires to the field of abortion. Only bottom feeder failures do. We’re all wondering if this video is legit for a reason.
You’re assuming because he’s “clean cut” and “nice looking” it would automatically send him to the top of his class in med school.
You also assume that doctors who perform abortions must all look like inbred street urchins, but then you go on about how much of a money making industry it is.
So couldn’t these docs afford to clean themselves up? Mani-pedi-facial after a long day of innocent slaughter?
JK, it’s a package. He appears to be conscientious, too. I’ve seen cute doctors who were jerks. I’ve seen ugly doctors who were conscientious. I’ve never seen cute and conscientious doctors who were abortionists.
So you’ve seen every single doctor who has ever performed an abortion?
Jill, what is an abortionist? Abortion clinic Doc or any doc who performs abortions?
The Ob/Gyn who delivered my children and performed our abortions was indeed top of his class, first class doctor, and many women think he’s very cute.
What’s a typical abortion doctor? What would differentiate them from this man? I don’t understand how he isn’t “typical.”
Well an abortionist’s looks don’t really matter. If he kills children, he’s a creep anyway. George Tiller looks like Jonn Wayne Gacy, Leroy Carhart scares the hageebers out of me. I wouldn’t want either one of them working on my reproductive organs. Carhart can’t even get his toupee on straight. Remember, it’s what’s on the inside.
Abortionist Leroy Carhart even got in trouble for animal abuse. His horses were taken away from him. They were standing knee deep in mud and they were malnourished.
I seriously don’t think that that has anything to do with his being an abortionist.
I don’t know about that. The guy has tons of cash. Maybe he’s got some serious psychological issues. He’s got a wife too. Why didn’t she take care of the animals? He was totally bent out of shape when his animals were taken from his property.
“They were standing knee deep in mud and they were malnourished.”
Ya.. .I can just imagine what sort of lot made those judgements. Horses were probably fine… otherwise we’d be seeing images of them all over the internet. Me thinks a couple pro-lifers were city officials and had vet grope out a problem.
Cameron, his neighbors called. Why would the animals be removed if the complaint was found to be unsubstantiated?
Living in an area that has many horses and seeing horses who have been abused I know that sometimes the owners don’t even know that they are abusing it. I mean, do you know how much a horse needs to eat a day? What about water, freash foods, they eat grass and hay from fields, maybe he thought that was enough? Maybe the horse had a gastrointestinal problem? My uncle feed his bird a rasin, the bird at it in one bite. My uncle thought the bird must like rasins, so he feed the bird a handfull. The bird exploded. Do you think my Uncle was evil? No, he was just trying to make the bird happy, and I’m sure the bird was thrilled with the rasins, I mean until it exploded.
Jess, I owned a horse. I am aware of their needs.
I think if I were to ask an abortionist anything (if I thought I’d get a candid answer), I would ask them what they had wanted to be when they were growing up. And whether any of those hopes and dreams as a child had been fulfilled.
I might also ask whether they feel truly appreciated by the pro-choice community for the work they do.
I’d ask if the path they have chosen has affected the relationship with the spouse, children, or friends, in any way.
Midnite,
I was responding to this:Just b/c he’s in a certain profession doesnt mean he is ugly on the outside..
Although now that I read it again I think you meant to say: Just b/c he’s in a certain profession doesn’t mean he is ugly on the inside…
That’s why I said Bundy was good looking on the outside, because you did…see?
I asked him, “Who exactly are you?”
All this nastiness is really uncalled for. Can any of you name a single abortionist who had a change of heart because prolifers were snotty and nasty to him?
Every single abortion worker I know of who had a change of heart was like Zaccheus in the New Testament — love came first, then redemption. Jesus didn’t slam Zaccheus. He just said, “I’m coming over for dinner.” The nearness of Jesus was enough to bring a total change of heart.
We’re supposed to be Jesus to this guy. How can we witness love to him if we’re throwing stones?
Just because his sin (if he is indeed an abortionist) is particularly loathsome to us does not excuse sinfulness on our part. We’re to preach the Good News to unbelievers. “You’re a slimebag and I hate you” isn’t the Good News.
Jesus died for each and every one of us WHILE WE WERE YET SINNERS.
Those among you without sin, keep casting stones.
Jess,
LMAO at the bird story :-)
What about raisins makes birds explode?
Christina,
Who was being mean? My questions at least, were legitimate. If I got to ask questions of a guy who cleaned up Elephant dung, I’d probably as him what soap he used also…
Jill asked us to pose questions…not as a way to belittle the man, but to try to find out how these guys live with themselves. Performing abortions is as foreign to me as living on Mars would be. So I’m asking questions that would reveal what makes him tick, and what it’s like to live in a “foreign land”…
Well the point is moot, anyone, any woman at least, can ask an abortion doc questions about anything if you don’t mind being charged for an office visit.
But I guess I’d ask: Would you feel comfortable delegating first-trimester abortions to a physician’s assistant, a nurse, or a nurse practicioner, assuming (s)he was properly trained and supervised by you?
But I guess I’d ask: Would you feel comfortable delegating first-trimester abortions to a physician’s assistant, a nurse, or a nurse practicioner, assuming (s)he was properly trained and supervised by you?
Are you actually asking pro-lifers this question?
No Beth,
He’s saying that that is what he’d ask the above abortionist.
I thought the question was, what would you ask an abortion doctor? That’s the question I’d suggest asking the abortion doctor.
My guess is he couldn’t make it in Medical school, and became a nurse practioner instead. Now he wants to know how he can get in on some of the cash action by performing them himself. I think he is also dying to get his feet wet..as well as his hands with some infants blood. The man is seriously twisted.
Not only does he approve of the likes of Tiller, but his highest aspiration in life is to finally get paid to do abortions himself…like his “heroes”
Oh okay, I totally misread it. My bad.
My guess is he couldn’t make it in Medical school, and became a nurse practioner instead. Now he wants to know how he can get in on some of the cash action by performing them himself. I think he is also dying to get his feet wet..as well as his hands with some infants blood. The man is seriously twisted.
Not only does he approve of the likes of Tiller, but his highest aspiration in life is to finally get paid to do abortions himself…like his “heroes”
That sounds right, MK.
Maybe that was SOMG.
I approve of Tiller for two reasons:
1. He’s the best there is (in the Western hemisphere; there are probably people with comparable experience in China) at what he does. If you’re a doctor and you have a patient who needs an abortion late in pregnancy, for whatever reason convinces you and the patient that she needs the abortion, you can count on Tiller to get it done with minimal trauma to the patient’s cervix and vagina. He has already encountered every possible complication and knows how to handle them. His safety record is unchallenged in the medical community.
2. He continues to provide abortion in spite of having been shot by a right-to-life terrorist. All victims of terror deserve a measure of respect, especially those who refuse to yield to the terrorist’s demands.
Hm, looks like the ‘ignoring those who bother us’ truce lasted about as long as I’d thought. I don’t understand how you all can’t see how much you drive people away from Christianity, from being pro-life. Why would anyone want to be part of a group that constantly snipes at their opponents, instead of using legitimate arguments? Suggesting that women who have abortions have psychopathic tendencies and that all abortion doctors are slimy, bottom of the barrel, doctors who flunked med school and that pro-choicers are devoid of any sort of moral values isn’t going to win any converts.
“My guess is he couldn’t make it in Medical school, and became a nurse practioner instead. Now he wants to know how he can get in on some of the cash action by performing them himself. I think he is also dying to get his feet wet..as well as his hands with some infants blood. The man is seriously twisted.
Not only does he approve of the likes of Tiller, but his highest aspiration in life is to finally get paid to do abortions himself…like his “heroes””
Are you talking about the guy in the video? Aren’t you presuming a whole lot about someone without even knowing them?
Did you guys click on his name to see the other video on his profile?
Where he walks in with OBVIOUSLY fake blood all over himself and jokes about leaving toes in a uterus?
This is pretty clearly NOT REAL.
Hey, Amanda, thanks for the heads up!
Less and Stephanie,
I was not referring to the doctor in the picture or all abortion doctors. My comment was to SMOG. We have a hate/hate relationship goin’ on.
As for comparing women who have had abortions to psychopaths…I’ve been over and over this…
If you can’t, won’t or don’t understand what I’m saying I don’t know what else I can do.
It is the same when we say abortion is murder. This does not translate into YOU ARE A MURDERER, because if you don’t understand that what you are doing is wrong, you are not in the same boat as say a Jeffrey Dahmer. I tried to make this point with Midnite once but all she could here was that women who have abortions are just like J.D…this is not what I meant at all. I simply meant that not understanding that abortion is murder leads one to commit this act without guilt. Which is what a sociopath does. Of course, it doesn’t mean you are the same, it simply means that the behavior is the same…
As for comparing abortion doctors to psychopaths…I make no apologies…
I don’t understand how you all can’t see how much you drive people away from Christianity, from being pro-life.
Are you suggesting that if we all acted “nice” you’d consider joining our side? I didn’t think so. You would “join” Christianity no matter what we did or said. You’ve made that clear.
And the truce was with everyone except Cam, SMOG, HisMan and Jasper…
When Smog gives an argument that can actually be debated, I’ll take him up on it. Until then, what would you have me say to someone who think George Tiller is an admirable human being. The man does 3rd trimester abortions and is proud of it. Even you say that abortions shouldn’t be done that late.
Since I firmly believe that he is as horrifying as Bundy, Gacy or Dahmer (Except he gets paid to do his despicable acts), I can feel free to talk about him the same way I would talk about any murderer.
Would you really talk about John Wayne Gacy in “nice”, “pleasant” terms? I’m sure he was a great guy…just had one flaw…he liked to cut up teenage boys and bury them under his house…but other than that he was awesome!?
Hm, looks like the ‘ignoring those who bother us’ truce lasted about as long as I’d thought. I don’t understand how you all can’t see how much you drive people away from Christianity, from being pro-life. Why would anyone want to be part of a group that constantly snipes at their opponents, instead of using legitimate arguments? Suggesting that women who have abortions have psychopathic tendencies and that all abortion doctors are slimy, bottom of the barrel, doctors who flunked med school and that pro-choicers are devoid of any sort of moral values isn’t going to win any converts.
Less, MK isn’t asking for SOMG to be censored or banned. You were asking that Jasper be censored.
Go ahead and poke fun at Jasper…I’m pretty sure he won’t care, and you won’t be breaking the “truce”. The whole point of the “truce” was because you and others seem to have a problem with Jasper or Hisman being allowed to post here.
As long as you aren’t trying to make this blog out to be hypocritical because Jasper and Hisman are allowed to post, there’s no problem. Obviously, if Jill was being more biased towards letting pro-lifers say whatever they want but deleting pro-choice insults, she would have deleted everything SOMG and Cameron ever say. This isn’t the case, as is obvious by looking through the posts here. I could probably find at least 100 insults by Cameron that have been left up by Jill. Plus, I know for a fact that some of Jasper’s posts have been deleted, some of Hisman’s have been deleted, etc. ANY posts which break the rules are deleted as soon as we find them. Doesn’t matter who they are.
Less, MK isn’t asking for SOMG to be censored or banned. You were asking that Jasper be censored.
But if he were to pass out with a chain saw…
Oh Lord, don’t give that man a chain saw!
Ask an abortion doc III
Yesterday our doc bragged on his personal best. And lest you think abortionists don’t keep fetuses in cold storage, here’s a 2005 shot from an actual abortion mill that belonged to fetus eater Krishna Rajanna. Read more about him here,…