Stupak voted to fund Planned Parenthood

From the Washington Times, March 23:

Bart Stupak: … I’ve done all I could as one member to protect the sanctity of life.
Reporter Kelly Picket: Then how come you didn’t vote for Pence’s amendment to de-fund Planned Parenthood back in 2009

services provided, abortion, planned parenthood, michigan.png

Bart Stupak: I don’t think I ever voted to de-fund Planned Parenthood. PP does not do abortions… in my district. PP has a number of clinics in my district that provide health care for my people….

Therefore, these clinics do quite well in my district, and I’m all for health care and extending it to everybody – access to health care, so that’s just another way. Also on PP, when they do it, there is a segregation of funds that go with it. It’s usually about four hundred million they tried to de-fund on PP.
Maybe this time, I’ll look at it again if Pence brings it up. Maybe I’ll vote differently this time, but you’re right I did vote against it.

The 2 PPs in Stupak’s district are located in Marquette and Petoskey.
Note by the chart above they both refer for abortion as well as enable abortions of the very young by BC and EC.
Bart Stupak is either parsing or unable to connect dots. Just because the 2 PP branches in his district, feeders and part of the United States’ largest abortion provider, do not actually commit the deed, they merely refer mothers to mills that commit the deed, he’s ok with that?
Furthermore, look at PP of MI’s 2010 goals. It expends its earnings and energy battling that which Stupak says he opposes, abortion.
Planned Parenthood NOrthern Michigan.png

28 thoughts on “Stupak voted to fund Planned Parenthood”

  1. Correct me if I’m wrong, but Mr. Stupak is supposedly Catholic, right?
    And doesn’t Planned Parenthood provide contraceptives?

  2. I wonder if this poor minor was taken to planned parenthood… this is just the kind of vile deceptive behaviour they like. wtf YES they should be defunded. They need to be defunded and banned from contact with minors.
    You won’t believe this:
    http://tinyurl.com/yjcfwln

  3. Where is this poor girls father? So high scool counselors now counsel children to lie to their parents while they go through the most traumatic times in their lives. How healthy is that. If this were my daughter my blood would boil and I would see nothing but red and I would convince these people never to do this to anybody ever again.

  4. Jill,
    Stupak is another member of the Knights of Columbus who has gone rogue on the life issues. He also voted to set up Clinton’s pro-abort offices worldwide.
    I’ve dubbed this creep “Black Bart, Black Knight”
    http://gerardnadal.com/2010/03/24/black-bart-black-knight/
    Also go to NRLC to check out his voting record. He knew damned well what he was doing with his votes. Would he ever have voted against a measure to defund a feeder organization for the KKK, or the Klan itself?
    ‘Nuff said.
    God Bless

  5. I didn’t vote to defund the Klan because they don’t do lynchings in my district. They do some great charitable work and I’m all for THAT.
    Stupak is a loser.

  6. I’m sure Stupak is going to be defeated in November. Bush won his district twice, and Obama barely took it.
    Now that the mask has been removed and he’s a fraud, I don’t think the voters there will stand for it.
    He’s got a couple of challengers, and one of them, Dan Benishek went from a few hundred facebook fans on Sunday to over 20,000 now, and he’s getting donations and doesn’t even have a web site yet.
    I really believe Bart will reap what he has sown.

  7. How can they get away with commiting abortion on a minor without notifying the legal guardian? It should be MANDATORY because a crime has been committed. These girls have been raped and they don’t notify the authorities or the legal guardian of the minor. They are right in our faces lobbying for laws that give them control of our daughters at the most delicate time in their young lives. She is scared and doesn’t know what to do and she may even be pro-life but gets counseled into making a decision she deeply regrets. I am sure that happens a lot. Vote all the Dumbocrats out, repeal Obamacare, and defund Planned Parenthood and ban them from “servicing” minors.

  8. 1If I speak in the tongues[a] of men and of angels, but have not love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. 2If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but have not love, I am nothing. 3If I give all I possess to the poor and surrender my body to the flames,[b] but have not love, I gain nothing.
    4Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. 5It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. 6Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. 7It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres.
    8Love never fails. But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away. 9For we know in part and we prophesy in part, 10but when perfection comes, the imperfect disappears. 11When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put childish ways behind me. 12Now we see but a poor reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.
    13And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love.
    1Cor 13:

  9. Yes Phil, this evil has come upon us cause as a nation we have chosen the path of Godlessness. Drive God out public gatherings and tear the family apart with divorce and same-sex marriage. Don’t think God doesn’t notice when the capital of the US. Washington DC. has become defiled with same-sex “marriage”; which is completely offensive to a holy God. We are headed down the path to Sodom and Gemorrah. May the Lord have mercy on us. May he shine his light upon us and give us the strength to do His work with our hands and to speak His words with our tongue and love God with our whole hearts and minds. And g xalisae along for the ride cause she is filled with the Holy Spirit wether she calls herself an atheist or not :)

  10. Should have said:
    And bring xalisae along for the ride cause she is filled with the Holy Spirit wether she calls herself an atheist or not :)

  11. What’s the difference between a stupak and a stupid? A kid. No…kids, a lot of kids….most of them murdered before birth.
    How many stupaks does it take to turn the greatest democracy man has ever known, that has done more good in the world, freed slaves, defeated Hitler, defeated Mussolini, defeated HiroHito, built the greatest free market economy ever known to man, fed the world, developed the greatest health care system in the world, sent the Gospel around the world, gave liberty to millions upon millions into a banana republic without firing a single shot? Just one.
    There’s these two guys I know with the first name of Bart. One’s on TV a lot, acts like a jerk, and gets a great deal of attention for his idiocy, can’t be taken seriously and really can’t be believed and isn’t that good looking. The other one’s a cartoon character. Can you help me with their last names?
    When I was a kid, one of my friends promised that if I helped him clean his yard he’d let me ride his new bike. Well, I cleaned his yard as he disappeared only to return after everything was done. Then he said, “sorry, it’s too dark now, I can’t let you ride my bike”. Well, I got angry, very, very, very, very angry.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? About 50 million more taxpayers.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? The word God on a blackboard.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? Prayer in the classroom.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? Taxes up the ying yang.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? The Sanctity of Marriage.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? The Rule of Law.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? Slaves that were made free and freemen that were made slaves.
    What’s the difference between a Democrat and a Republican? A race card (that’s race card not race car) powered Presidency and a law abiding Presidency.
    What will be the enduring legacy of high ideals of the Obama Presidency? OJ Simpson.
    What’s the difference between a president that claims to be a Christian but acts like a Muslim? Sorry, that’s above my pay grade.
    Obama does not want his daughters punished with a baby so he gave pro-lifers Bart Stupak.
    Was Obama a Muslim before he was Christian or a Christian before he was a Muslim? I’m going to go ask John Kerry and Bart Stupak.
    If Obama was a Muslim who became a Christian why wasn’t a fatwa issued against him? Perhaps Al-Qaeda knows something that we don’t.
    What’s the difference between Janet Napolitano and any other man? Again, that’s above my pay grade.
    What’s the main difference between Nancy Pelosi of New Jersey and Nancy Pelosi of California? About 300 Million Dollars and Nancy Pelosi of New Jersey would kick Nancy Pelosi of California’s ass in the 2010 election.
    Did Reid Lie or did Lie Reid? What, no difference?
    What’s the difference between an R-rated movie and Joe Biden’s typical speech with the President of the United States? Well, I’d let my child go to the movies but prevent her from watching TV at home.
    Why did Obama really pass health care “reform”? Because even Oprah couldn’t afford the giveaway.
    What’s the difference between a lotto ticket and an election ballot with a Democrat on it? With a lotto ticket your chances of taking other people’s money is about 1 in 432,456,274,585. But with a Democrat ballot, it’s a sure thing.
    Go buy tobacco and liquor stocks now. Those smokers and alcoholics that were paying higher health insurance premiums for their lifestyles will now have more money to spend on butts and booze.

  12. My goodness, Stupak is back to speaking rationally? He realized that if he voted to defund PP, he would have to answer the question ‘Why does he hate affordable healthcare for women?’
    He is absolutely correct that the two PP clinics in his district do not perform abortions. They do referrals. PP clinics all over the USA do more referrals than procedures (and some, like those in Stupak’s district, only do referrals).
    But bring in Jill’s crazies:
    Note by the chart on the right they both refer for abortion as well as enable abortions of the very young by BC and EC.
    BC and EC aren’t abortifacients. I’d ask you to deal with the truth, but you’ll never accept it. Because you’re crazy.
    And this highlights the sshort-sightedness of the Antis. They think PP is the center of America’s abortion practice. It’s not. It’s mainly city hospitals and isolated rural clinics staffed by attendings who do the actual work. Again, Antis don’t do their research or homework about this issue. They think PP is the head of the beast.
    Pssssssst. It’s NAF.

  13. Dhalgren – here’s healthcare for you:

    Planned Parenthood defends this dastardly practice, and did so at the highest court in the land.
    To call us crazy while you defend that is insanity epitomized.

  14. Dhalgren says “BC and EC aren’t abortifacients”
    We’ve been over this again and again. They act in a way to make the womb inhospitable, thus resulting in the deaths of embryonic humans.
    You are the one who needs to stop lying and educate yourself. Though since you’ve been told 100 times, I believe you are just being willfully ignorant.
    Oh, and PP doesn’t perform a single service (other than abortion) that a community health clinic can’t do. Nice try.

  15. Oh, and PP doesn’t perform a single service (other than abortion) that a community health clinic can’t do.
    Ah, but in some zip codes in America’s heartland and plains states, Planned Parenthood is one of the only clinics available to girls and women. I think Bart Stupak knows this.
    Also, Family Planning is a vital service. It’s not as if PP is offering a redundant or frivolous service. Family Planning is a pillar of women’s healthcare. And if a woman lives in a zip code that doesn’t have a full OBGYN department in a hospital, PP is the place to go for regular exams and birth control.

  16. Dhalgren,
    Just because you claim something to be true, doesn’t make it so. Do the research on how oral contraceptives work or how IUDs work and then get back to us.
    As a Catholic, Bart Stupak should not be supporting PP whether or not his local clinics actually perform the procedure. It is bad enough that the clinics provide birth control which often leads to more abortions. As a matter of fact, 60% of women who procure abortions were contracepting at the time of conception. You can check the Guttmacher Institute for verification.
    Frankly, it’s getting harder and harder to take your posts seriously.

  17. Dhalgren wrote:
    Ah, but in some zip codes in America’s heartland and plains states, Planned Parenthood is one of the only clinics available to girls and women. I think Bart Stupak knows this.
    What, do the other clinics have “No Girls Allowed!” signs on their front doors? Are doctors working in the Li’l Rascals’ clubhouse now?
    Seriously, I live in a pretty small town, and we have a few doctors’ offices and an urgent-care clinic. Strangely, no Planned Parenthood … not that I’m complaining!
    Can you provide a concrete example of a PP clinic being the only medical care available to women? I don’t know that you’re wrong … but the claim seems a bit sketchy to me, so I’d like proof.

  18. Chris:
    That is the face of abortion…..the reality of abortion.
    And the vast majority of pro-aborts deny this.
    The entire world needs to see the face of abortion.
    Hey Dhalgren: It’s not rhetoric, it’s a baby.

  19. Haha. Good luck chasing this train. I’ve tried many, many, MANY times before, and at this point, I don’t even bother anymore. I just say that while abortion on demand is legal, we are allies, and I should treat them like allies, and until real (ACTUAL) abortion is illegal, we’re on the same page.
    Birth control…not so much.

  20. Ashley,
    Your arguments are a joke. Your assertion regarding NFP is particularly ridiculous. In NFP there is no chemical or physical alteration of the womb environment. So any fertilized egg that is expelled is truly due to natural causes – not man-made ones.
    I’m glad you find birth control pills so “laughable.” Try looking into the link between BCPs and breast cancer and then laugh. Try looking into water contamination from oral contraceptives, then laugh.
    And when will pro-aborts realize that this issue is about protecting LIFE, regardless of age, stage or development?

  21. OK Ashley:
    So you think size matters? I don’t think God thinks size matters.
    I mean look at how big you are relative to the Universe, relative to God. You aren’t even a speck.
    Should God, because of your relative size, say about you what you say about “just a clump of cells” that you think no one cares about? I do believe God cares and, if He cares, guess what, we should all lend an ear.
    Let me clue you in since you are well, clueless.
    It’s not just the physical part of an unborn child that pro-lifers are concerned about. It’s the baby’s immortal soul (yes, that invisible, undetectable, and no-size part) as the expression of God’s will embodied in every single conception that we are concerned about and even more so. Guess what….God is concerned too….real, real concerned. I mean, one can foolishly provoke a divine response if one really, really tries.
    You see, when a child is conceived, God, from the beginning of time had a plan for that child. And what does an abortion do? You got it….it messes with God’s will. Not a very smart thing to do. Natural processes, you know, those instituted and created by God, well, they’re natural, i.e., consistent with His will.
    So, to somehow embrace and express some sick, self-satisfying lies about Jill Stanek as a justification for abortion, is really, really ignorant, i.e., demonstrates a complete lack of understanding.
    My guess is that you’re young and immature and really haven’t thought about this to any really deep level. Either that or you’re a real, real shallow person.
    Think some more and don’t use your own perspective. Think outside your close-minded box.

  22. Wouldn’t you like to know more about Planned Parenthood’s REAL views? There is a documentary called: Maafa21 Black Genocide in 21st Century America and the producers of Maafa21 went directly to the source, researching the information from the papers of Margaret Sanger , Planned Parenthood, and their board. Maafa21 documents that Margaret Sanger – founder of Planned Parenthood was an avowed racist who delivered a stunning pro-KLAN speech to the KKK and that Sanger , by her own admission, was invited by the racist and violent KLAN, to deliver at least 12 additional speeches to their members. Sanger was also an avowed eugenicist and a 100% committed member of the American Eugenics Society. Lovely, huh? Today, Planned Parenthood’s highest award the “Margaret Sanger Award” is named in her “honor” of this former Klan speaker, shocking ! And now the American taxpayer will be forced to fund them to even more, more shocking ! There is a targeting going on and African Americans are in the crossfires. Planned Parenthood kills more African Americans babies through abortion and the numbers continue to grow. Any wonder why the Government is pushing abortion in health care so they can carry on this Eugenic plan? Listen to the words of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who told the New York Magazine in July of 2009, that she thought abortion was legalized to QUOTE, “get rid of the populations we no longer wanted” Just who are these “populations” Ginsburg and Planned Parenthood’s founder “no longer wants” find out by watching Maafa21 http://www.maafa21.com

Comments are closed.